Re: directions, polarity reverse - Off Topic

Status
Not open for further replies.

O Ilusionista

Captain 100K
It takes some getting used to, i have experimented with Goldeneye, Doom , Quake, a little bit of Doom3 & MUGEN, after dealing with those, OpenBor is a bit odd for some of the stuff that you may want to do...

oldyz Excluding GoldenEye, I've tried all the other engines you mention - specially Mugen, since I have 20 years of experience - and I can say that OpenBOR is more user friendly than most of the engines you mentioned.

The key of a tool is: know WHICH tool you should use for WHAT. There is the fork, there is the spoon. As I usually say: can you have soup with a fork? You can, but there is something "better" for that. Can you eat barbecue with a spoon? You can, but there is something "better" for that. Pay attention to the words "better"and "that".

I know I'm going to seem biased because I'm part of the team, but I really like the engine. I didn't like it in the past (I met it at the time of BOR), but today I love it.

Here comes the conversation about tools and their use. But, most of the time, I prefer to work on OpenBOR than on Mugen, from the engine point of view - ok, there are other points that influence my judgment, like the toxicity of mugen communities, but I don't want to turn this post into a Mugen X OpenBOR - one day I will do a topic like this, sharing my experiences and I will call some friends.

sometimes the manual has undocumented things
Really, in the past, that was true - and it was something that frustrated me. But I started a project to document everything the engine has and, with the help of several friends, I can say that I achieved a very high rate. You can check it out here - http://www.chronocrash.com/forum/index.php?topic=2022.0
 
O Ilusionista

I don't know exactly where our OP "comes from", but in my case one of the main problems is that i got used to using too many visual editors.

Also the common denominator is that i try to do things beyond what the engines are capable of & to add to that is the fact that my first experience modding is with the Goldeneye folks.
With them, if you get your level to a certain degree of completion , some of the members actually end up coding some stuff for you, because they are pretty much the only ones that can & the visual editor can't do it, & for certain things, like reload animations, there is one or 2 guys that take care of them really quick...
the main "problem" with them is the fact that they want the stuff to be playable in the console, & that limits a lot of the stuff you can do... & what the engine could actually pull off, game-play wise & internet wise

Mugen/IKEMEN is harder than Openbor, because if im not mistaken the engine is restricted, (last time i checked) & its kinda broken.
Again, things that i would like to have , like team elimination (KI GOLD) for 4 players, Dynamic backgrounds (KI & KI2) that can zoom in & out, Zoom deltas, Platforms (smash brothers), & 3+ on 3+ combat (Mortal Kombat trilogy)
all this , is not possible unless you code it or script it in... i have not met the toxicity, but i guess i never got far enough...

long story short, I've had it easy with the visual editors, so my ability to make mental images of how values work is a bit stunted
 
Mugen/IKEMEN is harder than Openbor, because if im not mistaken the engine is restricted, (last time i checked) & its kinda broken.

oldyz I think I have to disagree with you strongly here. I have enough experience to tell you the engine is far, far away from being broken.
It's not because you want to do something and the engine "can't" do it that the engine is broken. Broken is something which doesn't works.

This is one of the most common mistakes newcomers do in both engine (Mugen and OpenBOR). I can tell you that I saw this type of error (user doesn't know what he is doing, blames the engine then discover it was his own fault) once a week, at least.

Again, things that i would like to have , like team elimination (KI GOLD) for 4 players, Dynamic backgrounds (KI & KI2) that can zoom in & out, Zoom deltas, Platforms (smash brothers), & 3+ on 3+ combat (Mortal Kombat trilogy)
Everything you mentioned is already possible in OpenBOR and in Mugen (yeah really) :)

all this , is not possible unless you code it or script it in
This is what a coder do - Everything you do on an engine is coding, in certain level :)

My bad, we've had derailed the topic a lot. Lets stick the OP post, or it would be better to split this topic.


 
OK, this has clearly gone off the rails and is about to end up a round robin. Time to shut it down. I'm splitting away the off topic talk and locking it. In a few days it will be moved to admin area.

DC
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom